Skip to content

Objections Stall Settlement to Pay NCAA Student-Athletes

On the same day the Florida Gators edged out the Houston Cougars 65-63 in the 2025 NCAA March Madness men’s basketball championship game, a California federal judge weighed objections to a ground-breaking agreement to permit schools to directly pay student-athletes for playing.

The preliminary $2.8 billion settlement (dubbed the “House Settlement”), initially reached in October 2024, would permit colleges and universities to pay student-athletes and end three antitrust lawsuits filed against the NCAA and five major conferences. The judge refused to grant the House Settlement final approval during the April 7, 2025, hearing; instead, she gave the parties time to address a variety of objections raised and propose solutions.

In this Chicago Daily Law Bulletin article authored by Douglas Masters, managing partner of Loeb & Loeb’s Chicago office, and Advanced Media & Technology partner Seth Rose, the writers discuss how objections to the proposed $2.8 billion House Settlement have delayed a potentially transformative shift toward allowing colleges to directly pay student-athletes, while signaling continued evolution of the NIL and college sports compensation landscape.