The U.S. Supreme Court has declined to review the Fifth Circuit’s novel ruling in BMG Rights Management v. Vetter that the statutory termination of a grant of copyright in a U.S. work applies worldwide, notwithstanding the statutory proviso that termination “in no way affects rights arising under any other Federal, State, or foreign laws.” This also leaves intact the Fifth Circuit’s corresponding ruling that when an author of a pre-1978 work dies before the end of the original 28-year copyright term, the renewal term reverts to the author’s heirs on a worldwide basis as well. Although the Fifth Circuit’s ruling only binds courts within its geographic boundaries—which include Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi—it threatens to upend long-held industry assumptions about the limited territorial reach of U.S. copyright law.
Facts of the Vetter Case
The dispute dates back to the early 1960s, when Cyril Vetter and Don Smith co-wrote the song “Double Shot (Of My Baby’s Love)” in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. Vetter and Smith assigned all of their worldwide interests in the song—including their renewal term interests under the 1909 Copyright Act—to Windsong Music Publishers in exchange for $1 and a promise to pay future royalties. Vetter later acquired Smith’s renewal term interest from Smith’s heirs, who had inherited Smith’s renewal term rights because Smith died before the start of the renewal term. In 2019, Vetter terminated his assignment of rights to Windsong under Section 304(c) of the 1976 Copyright Act, which permits authors or their heirs to recapture copyright interests in pre-1978 works 56 years after the work was copyrighted. When ABC sought to use “Double Shot” in a television episode to be broadcast worldwide, defendants Robert Resnik and his company, the successors to Windsong, argued that Vetter’s recaptured interest and renewal term interest were limited to the United States. In 2023, Vetter filed a declaratory judgment action in Louisiana federal court, seeking a ruling that he owned all copyright interests in the song worldwide. The district court denied defendants’ motion to dismiss (read our summary of the district court’s decision here) and later granted summary judgment for Vetter, declaring him and his company the sole owners of the song’s copyright worldwide.
The Fifth Circuit’s Novel Ruling
In January 2026, the Fifth Circuit affirmed. (Read our summary of the Fifth Circuit’s decision here.) As to termination under the 1976 Copyright Act, the panel focused on the following language in Section 304(c)(6)(E) of the act: “Termination of a grant under this subsection affects only those rights covered by the grant that arise under this title, and in no way affects rights arising under any other Federal, State, or foreign laws.” The court held that the rights subject to termination are those that “arise under this title,” which it interpreted to mean rights created in accordance with the U.S. Copyright Act. The court was not clear, however, whether this conclusion was driven by the fact that the song was written in the United States or by the fact that Vetter’s and Smith’s assignment contained a choice of law provision in favor of New York law. In any case, the court held that the work has a single copyright that is created by U.S. law and recognized by other countries under international copyright treaties, such as the Berne Convention and the Universal Copyright Convention. On that premise, the Fifth Circuit held that the plain language of the termination statute requires that all rights arising under U.S. copyright law—as well as Vetter’s copyright “to the extent that it extends internationally”—be subject to recapture.
The Fifth Circuit drew support for its conclusion from Kirtsaeng v. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., where the Supreme Court adopted a non-geographical interpretation of the phrase “lawfully made under this title,” albeit in the different context of applying the first-sale doctrine to textbooks manufactured outside the United States. The Fifth Circuit also reasoned that applying termination worldwide would accord with congressional intent to “safeguard against an unremunerative transfer and help correct for the unequal bargaining power” between authors and grantees. The court declined to follow courts from within the Second and Ninth Circuits, which had held that termination applies only to rights in the United States, characterizing those cases as relying on weak reasoning, being nonbinding and resting on treatises that focus on the territorial limits of copyright infringement rather than copyright ownership.
As to the renewal term copyright, the Fifth Circuit similarly held that the 1909 Copyright Act’s renewal provision contains no geographical limitation, and that worldwide recapture would be consistent with the purpose of the renewal term to provide authors or their heirs with an entirely “new estate.” This made Vetter’s company the sole owner of the renewal interest worldwide.
The Supreme Court Punts
Following the Fifth Circuit’s ruling, a group of major music publishers acquired Resnik’s interest in “Double Shot” and were substituted as parties to the case for the express purpose of seeking Supreme Court review. However, on October 19, the Supreme Court issued a brief order indicating that it lacked a quorum to review the case, as Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Neil Gorsuch, Amy Coney Barrett and Ketanji Brown Jackson had recused themselves. Although the Court’s order gave no reasons for the recusals, it has been reported that those four justices recused themselves because they have book deals with Penguin Random House, which is a corporate affiliate of one of the petitioners, BMG Rights Management (US) LLC. The result keeps worldwide ownership of “Double Shot” with Vetter and his company.
Why It Matters
The Fifth Circuit’s ruling departs from roughly 50 years of industry practice and understanding that statutory termination affects only U.S. rights. At least in the Fifth Circuit, that limitation no longer applies. To the extent the Fifth Circuit’s ruling applies, it is likely to have significant impacts throughout the entertainment industry.
Music industry. The most immediate effect is on foreign income. Until now, a songwriter who terminated a grant recaptured only the U.S. copyright, while the publisher kept the song’s foreign rights and associated royalties. Under Vetter, those foreign royalties may now revert to a terminating author or their heirs, along with control over foreign licensing. This will likely affect the economics of catalog sales, particularly where the ex-U.S. royalty stream is substantial.
Vetter’s practical impact on the music industry will be tempered by two statutory exceptions to termination. First, the 1976 Copyright Act’s termination provisions expressly exclude works made for hire. As a result, record labels that own sound recordings and music publishers that own musical compositions under valid work-for-hire agreements are insulated from termination—whether in the United States or elsewhere. The same is true for renewal term reversion of pre-1978 works under the 1909 Copyright Act. Both the original and renewal terms of copyright are owned by the putative employer when the work was made for hire, even if the author dies before the start of the renewal term. Whether a sound recording or musical composition qualifies as a work made for hire depends on a variety of factors that are outside the scope of this alert.
Second, under the termination statute’s derivative works exception, derivative works prepared under the terms of a grant of copyright may continue to be exploited even after termination. As a result, films and television programming that incorporate a sound recording and its underlying musical composition may continue to be distributed even after the artist or songwriter terminates the grant of rights. Likewise, because a sound recording is a derivative of a musical composition, record labels may continue to exploit sound recordings created and distributed pursuant to a pre-termination license. As an important exception, however, performing rights organizations and the Mechanical Licensing Collective have adopted policies of paying post-termination royalties to the terminating author or their new publisher. Moreover, the derivative works exception does not apply to pre-1978 works when the renewal term reverts to the author’s heirs. Heirs of authors of pre-1978 works that are still in their renewal term can thus potentially block the distribution of films, television programs and recordings that contain the author’s works. After Vetter, that leverage may extend worldwide.
Film industry. Vetter also threatens to unsettle a long-standing practice in the film industry. Although motion pictures themselves are often created as works made for hire and are therefore immune from termination, a grant of rights to a screenplay or book used to create a film may be subject to termination. While the licensed film or television program itself is a derivative work that can still be exploited after termination, a terminating screenwriter or book author could, in theory, license their work for the creation of a new film or television program after termination. Movie studios and television producers frequently use their retained foreign rights to block such remakes, as films and television programs often cannot be produced without the prospect of worldwide distribution. Vetter’s holding that authors can recapture their rights worldwide puts that paradigm in jeopardy.
What To Expect Going Forward
Forum shopping. The Fifth Circuit’s ruling binds only federal courts in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi. Courts elsewhere, including in the Second and Ninth Circuits, have reached the opposite conclusion. That divergence in the law creates an incentive for forum shopping. Authors will no doubt seek to bring infringement and declaratory judgment actions in the Fifth Circuit to confirm worldwide post-termination rights. Copyright grantees and licensees will likely file suit elsewhere and potentially try to bring the issue back to the Supreme Court to overturn Vetter. Alternatively, if the grantee continues exploiting foreign rights and the terminating author waits more than three years to file suit, the grantee may raise a statute of limitations defense, as the limitations period for copyright ownership claims accrues only once when the author has notice that the grantee is claiming rights contrary to theirs.
Enforcement challenges abroad. In order for authors to reap the benefits of worldwide termination that Vetter promises, they may need to enforce their termination rights against publishers, licensees and collection societies exploiting the work and collecting revenues outside the United States. This is especially true if different entities exploit the work and collect revenues in the United States and abroad, as the foreign licensee or collection society may not be subject to jurisdiction in a U.S. court. It is unclear, however, whether courts in another country will recognize termination under the U.S. Copyright Act as affecting rights in that foreign country, even if a U.S. court has reached that conclusion.
Uncertainty for foreign authors. Before Vetter, there was little question that foreign authors had the same ability as U.S. authors to terminate grants of rights to their works in the United States. The Fifth Circuit’s reasoning in Vetter casts doubt on that parity. The court adopted the principle that a work is subject to one copyright under the laws of one jurisdiction, which must then be recognized in other countries, and that only copyrights arising under U.S. law are subject to termination. Publishers and other grantees may take the position that foreign works, and grants that are subject to foreign law, do not arise under U.S. law and are therefore not subject to termination. This would leave foreign authors with fewer rights under the U.S. Copyright Act than U.S. writers, arguably violating the Berne Convention’s principle of national treatment, which requires that each member country give foreign authors the same protections it gives its own. Whether courts exclude foreign authors from the U.S. Copyright Act’s termination regime is yet to be determined.
Changing deal economics. Although Vetter is binding only in the Fifth Circuit, and its ruling may still be overturned by the Supreme Court in another litigation, it raises a risk that termination will be effective worldwide. This will no doubt affect negotiations—whether between authors and their original grantees trying to reach a new deal after a notice of termination has been served but before it becomes effective, between a terminating author and a new grantee after termination, or between an original grantee and a buyer of foreign rights after termination. Authors and their post-termination grantees will try to use the threat of recapturing worldwide rights under Vetter to negotiate better economic terms both in the United States and abroad, especially if there is a prospect of them filing suit in the Fifth Circuit.
Conclusion
By declining to review Vetter, the Supreme Court left in place a ruling that, at least within the Fifth Circuit, allows authors and their heirs to recapture copyrights worldwide through statutory termination and renewal reversion. Until another circuit adopts the Fifth Circuit’s reasoning or the Supreme Court resolves the split with other courts, the territorial reach of termination will remain uncertain and may depend on where a dispute is litigated. Until the issue is settled on a nationwide basis, authors, publishers, record labels, studios, and other grantees and licensees should reassess the value of their catalogs and foreign income streams, review whether their works qualify for the work made-for-hire or derivative works exceptions, and account for the risk of worldwide recapture in pending and future negotiations.
Facts of the Vetter Case
The dispute dates back to the early 1960s, when Cyril Vetter and Don Smith co-wrote the song “Double Shot (Of My Baby’s Love)” in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. Vetter and Smith assigned all of their worldwide interests in the song—including their renewal term interests under the 1909 Copyright Act—to Windsong Music Publishers in exchange for $1 and a promise to pay future royalties. Vetter later acquired Smith’s renewal term interest from Smith’s heirs, who had inherited Smith’s renewal term rights because Smith died before the start of the renewal term. In 2019, Vetter terminated his assignment of rights to Windsong under Section 304(c) of the 1976 Copyright Act, which permits authors or their heirs to recapture copyright interests in pre-1978 works 56 years after the work was copyrighted. When ABC sought to use “Double Shot” in a television episode to be broadcast worldwide, defendants Robert Resnik and his company, the successors to Windsong, argued that Vetter’s recaptured interest and renewal term interest were limited to the United States. In 2023, Vetter filed a declaratory judgment action in Louisiana federal court, seeking a ruling that he owned all copyright interests in the song worldwide. The district court denied defendants’ motion to dismiss (read our summary of the district court’s decision here) and later granted summary judgment for Vetter, declaring him and his company the sole owners of the song’s copyright worldwide.
The Fifth Circuit’s Novel Ruling
In January 2026, the Fifth Circuit affirmed. (Read our summary of the Fifth Circuit’s decision here.) As to termination under the 1976 Copyright Act, the panel focused on the following language in Section 304(c)(6)(E) of the act: “Termination of a grant under this subsection affects only those rights covered by the grant that arise under this title, and in no way affects rights arising under any other Federal, State, or foreign laws.” The court held that the rights subject to termination are those that “arise under this title,” which it interpreted to mean rights created in accordance with the U.S. Copyright Act. The court was not clear, however, whether this conclusion was driven by the fact that the song was written in the United States or by the fact that Vetter’s and Smith’s assignment contained a choice of law provision in favor of New York law. In any case, the court held that the work has a single copyright that is created by U.S. law and recognized by other countries under international copyright treaties, such as the Berne Convention and the Universal Copyright Convention. On that premise, the Fifth Circuit held that the plain language of the termination statute requires that all rights arising under U.S. copyright law—as well as Vetter’s copyright “to the extent that it extends internationally”—be subject to recapture.
The Fifth Circuit drew support for its conclusion from Kirtsaeng v. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., where the Supreme Court adopted a non-geographical interpretation of the phrase “lawfully made under this title,” albeit in the different context of applying the first-sale doctrine to textbooks manufactured outside the United States. The Fifth Circuit also reasoned that applying termination worldwide would accord with congressional intent to “safeguard against an unremunerative transfer and help correct for the unequal bargaining power” between authors and grantees. The court declined to follow courts from within the Second and Ninth Circuits, which had held that termination applies only to rights in the United States, characterizing those cases as relying on weak reasoning, being nonbinding and resting on treatises that focus on the territorial limits of copyright infringement rather than copyright ownership.
As to the renewal term copyright, the Fifth Circuit similarly held that the 1909 Copyright Act’s renewal provision contains no geographical limitation, and that worldwide recapture would be consistent with the purpose of the renewal term to provide authors or their heirs with an entirely “new estate.” This made Vetter’s company the sole owner of the renewal interest worldwide.
The Supreme Court Punts
Following the Fifth Circuit’s ruling, a group of major music publishers acquired Resnik’s interest in “Double Shot” and were substituted as parties to the case for the express purpose of seeking Supreme Court review. However, on October 19, the Supreme Court issued a brief order indicating that it lacked a quorum to review the case, as Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Neil Gorsuch, Amy Coney Barrett and Ketanji Brown Jackson had recused themselves. Although the Court’s order gave no reasons for the recusals, it has been reported that those four justices recused themselves because they have book deals with Penguin Random House, which is a corporate affiliate of one of the petitioners, BMG Rights Management (US) LLC. The result keeps worldwide ownership of “Double Shot” with Vetter and his company.
Why It Matters
The Fifth Circuit’s ruling departs from roughly 50 years of industry practice and understanding that statutory termination affects only U.S. rights. At least in the Fifth Circuit, that limitation no longer applies. To the extent the Fifth Circuit’s ruling applies, it is likely to have significant impacts throughout the entertainment industry.
Music industry. The most immediate effect is on foreign income. Until now, a songwriter who terminated a grant recaptured only the U.S. copyright, while the publisher kept the song’s foreign rights and associated royalties. Under Vetter, those foreign royalties may now revert to a terminating author or their heirs, along with control over foreign licensing. This will likely affect the economics of catalog sales, particularly where the ex-U.S. royalty stream is substantial.
Vetter’s practical impact on the music industry will be tempered by two statutory exceptions to termination. First, the 1976 Copyright Act’s termination provisions expressly exclude works made for hire. As a result, record labels that own sound recordings and music publishers that own musical compositions under valid work-for-hire agreements are insulated from termination—whether in the United States or elsewhere. The same is true for renewal term reversion of pre-1978 works under the 1909 Copyright Act. Both the original and renewal terms of copyright are owned by the putative employer when the work was made for hire, even if the author dies before the start of the renewal term. Whether a sound recording or musical composition qualifies as a work made for hire depends on a variety of factors that are outside the scope of this alert.
Second, under the termination statute’s derivative works exception, derivative works prepared under the terms of a grant of copyright may continue to be exploited even after termination. As a result, films and television programming that incorporate a sound recording and its underlying musical composition may continue to be distributed even after the artist or songwriter terminates the grant of rights. Likewise, because a sound recording is a derivative of a musical composition, record labels may continue to exploit sound recordings created and distributed pursuant to a pre-termination license. As an important exception, however, performing rights organizations and the Mechanical Licensing Collective have adopted policies of paying post-termination royalties to the terminating author or their new publisher. Moreover, the derivative works exception does not apply to pre-1978 works when the renewal term reverts to the author’s heirs. Heirs of authors of pre-1978 works that are still in their renewal term can thus potentially block the distribution of films, television programs and recordings that contain the author’s works. After Vetter, that leverage may extend worldwide.
Film industry. Vetter also threatens to unsettle a long-standing practice in the film industry. Although motion pictures themselves are often created as works made for hire and are therefore immune from termination, a grant of rights to a screenplay or book used to create a film may be subject to termination. While the licensed film or television program itself is a derivative work that can still be exploited after termination, a terminating screenwriter or book author could, in theory, license their work for the creation of a new film or television program after termination. Movie studios and television producers frequently use their retained foreign rights to block such remakes, as films and television programs often cannot be produced without the prospect of worldwide distribution. Vetter’s holding that authors can recapture their rights worldwide puts that paradigm in jeopardy.
What To Expect Going Forward
Forum shopping. The Fifth Circuit’s ruling binds only federal courts in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi. Courts elsewhere, including in the Second and Ninth Circuits, have reached the opposite conclusion. That divergence in the law creates an incentive for forum shopping. Authors will no doubt seek to bring infringement and declaratory judgment actions in the Fifth Circuit to confirm worldwide post-termination rights. Copyright grantees and licensees will likely file suit elsewhere and potentially try to bring the issue back to the Supreme Court to overturn Vetter. Alternatively, if the grantee continues exploiting foreign rights and the terminating author waits more than three years to file suit, the grantee may raise a statute of limitations defense, as the limitations period for copyright ownership claims accrues only once when the author has notice that the grantee is claiming rights contrary to theirs.
Enforcement challenges abroad. In order for authors to reap the benefits of worldwide termination that Vetter promises, they may need to enforce their termination rights against publishers, licensees and collection societies exploiting the work and collecting revenues outside the United States. This is especially true if different entities exploit the work and collect revenues in the United States and abroad, as the foreign licensee or collection society may not be subject to jurisdiction in a U.S. court. It is unclear, however, whether courts in another country will recognize termination under the U.S. Copyright Act as affecting rights in that foreign country, even if a U.S. court has reached that conclusion.
Uncertainty for foreign authors. Before Vetter, there was little question that foreign authors had the same ability as U.S. authors to terminate grants of rights to their works in the United States. The Fifth Circuit’s reasoning in Vetter casts doubt on that parity. The court adopted the principle that a work is subject to one copyright under the laws of one jurisdiction, which must then be recognized in other countries, and that only copyrights arising under U.S. law are subject to termination. Publishers and other grantees may take the position that foreign works, and grants that are subject to foreign law, do not arise under U.S. law and are therefore not subject to termination. This would leave foreign authors with fewer rights under the U.S. Copyright Act than U.S. writers, arguably violating the Berne Convention’s principle of national treatment, which requires that each member country give foreign authors the same protections it gives its own. Whether courts exclude foreign authors from the U.S. Copyright Act’s termination regime is yet to be determined.
Changing deal economics. Although Vetter is binding only in the Fifth Circuit, and its ruling may still be overturned by the Supreme Court in another litigation, it raises a risk that termination will be effective worldwide. This will no doubt affect negotiations—whether between authors and their original grantees trying to reach a new deal after a notice of termination has been served but before it becomes effective, between a terminating author and a new grantee after termination, or between an original grantee and a buyer of foreign rights after termination. Authors and their post-termination grantees will try to use the threat of recapturing worldwide rights under Vetter to negotiate better economic terms both in the United States and abroad, especially if there is a prospect of them filing suit in the Fifth Circuit.
Conclusion
By declining to review Vetter, the Supreme Court left in place a ruling that, at least within the Fifth Circuit, allows authors and their heirs to recapture copyrights worldwide through statutory termination and renewal reversion. Until another circuit adopts the Fifth Circuit’s reasoning or the Supreme Court resolves the split with other courts, the territorial reach of termination will remain uncertain and may depend on where a dispute is litigated. Until the issue is settled on a nationwide basis, authors, publishers, record labels, studios, and other grantees and licensees should reassess the value of their catalogs and foreign income streams, review whether their works qualify for the work made-for-hire or derivative works exceptions, and account for the risk of worldwide recapture in pending and future negotiations.
-
合伙人